Co-ownership disputes
When two or more people own property together and fall out, the property can become a trap. Siblings who inherited a house, relatives or friends who bought together, parents and adult children, business partners and investors all end up in these disputes. We act in co-ownership disputes of every kind. Separating couples' property is dealt with under family law instead. Property settlement
What can I do if my co-owner will not agree to sell?
First, negotiate: one owner may buy the other out, or both may agree to sell. Mediation often helps. If there is still no agreement, a co-owner can apply to the court under the Law of Property Act 1936 (SA) for an order that the property be sold and the proceeds divided, without having to ask for the land to be divided (s 83). If the owners asking for a sale hold half or more of the property, the court "shall, unless it sees good reason to the contrary, direct a sale" (s 70). If they hold less, the court can still order a sale despite the others' dissent where a sale would be more beneficial than dividing the land (s 69(2)).
The onus is on the owner opposing sale, and a sale is an alternative to dividing the land, not to leaving things as they are: Szymanska v Szymanski [2015] SASC 126 at [15]–[16], applying Bray v Bray [1926] HCA 40, where Higgins J said: "I regard a sale as an alternative to a partition and not to the status quo". "The mere fact that one of the co-owners ... objects to sale is not a good reason against an order for sale", even where the objection is sentimental: Karastamatis v Tzanavaras [2013] SASC 163 at [20]. Hardship goes at most to a merciful deferral of enforcement, not to the right to an order: Szymanska at [17]–[18].
The objecting owners can keep the property by undertaking to buy the applicant's share at a valuation (s 71). In Karastamatis the court allowed time for such a purchase before ordering a public auction (at [24]). Whether s 71 lets the court order a co-owner who did not ask for a sale to sell their share to another co-owner is arguable: Van der Wolff v Van der Wolff [2024] SASCA 125 at [19]–[21]. That does not affect the right to a sale under s 70.
How are the proceeds divided?
The starting point is the shares recorded on the title: equal shares for joint tenants, and the stated shares for tenants in common. The court can then make adjustments for who paid the deposit, the mortgage, rates, insurance and improvements. Where the owners contributed very unequally, the property may be held on trust in different shares from those on the title.
My co-owner lives in the property and I do not. Can I charge them rent?
Generally not, unless they have excluded you. But if the co-owner in occupation claims credit for paying the mortgage or improving the property, the value of their occupation can be set off against that claim.
Can I sell or transfer my share without my co-owner's consent?
A tenant in common can usually deal with their own share. A joint tenant can sever the joint tenancy without the other owner's consent, which turns it into a tenancy in common and ends the right of survivorship. But it takes an act that operates on the joint tenant's own share: "a statement of intention, without more, does not affect the unity of title": Corin v Patton [1990] HCA 12 at [7]–[10]. A letter or notice to the other owner announcing the severance is therefore not enough.
In South Australia the usual method is a transfer by the joint tenant of their interest to themselves, which s 40(3) of the Law of Property Act 1936 (SA) allows. Under s 67 of the Real Property Act 1886 (SA), a registrable instrument passes no interest until it is registered, so the severance takes effect only when the transfer is registered on the title. In Lyko v Derkatch [2018] SADC 90 at [327]–[328], [376], a joint tenant's transfer to himself that was signed and lodged but never registered did not sever the joint tenancy; see also Peldan v Anderson [2006] HCA 48 at [20]. If the joint tenant dies before the transfer is registered, the survivor takes the whole property.
Unlike New South Wales and Queensland, South Australia has no express statutory power of unilateral severance, and no South Australian appellate court has yet decided the point. Severing has consequences for what happens on death, so take advice first.
What if the property was a family arrangement?
Family arrangements, such as parents helping with a child's purchase or a granny flat on a child's land, often have nothing in writing. Whether money was a gift or a loan, and what was promised, decide who owns what. Read about promises of an inheritance
What happens when a co-owner dies?
If they were a joint tenant, the surviving owner takes the whole property. If they were a tenant in common, their share passes to their estate, and the survivor becomes co-owner with the executor or the beneficiaries. Read about deceased estates
How we help
-
negotiating buy-outs and agreed sales
-
mediation between co-owners
-
court applications for sale and division of the proceeds
-
claims for contributions, improvements and occupation
-
disputes about family arrangements and trusts over property
To talk to us about a co-owned property, call 08 8393 1234 or use our contact form.
General information about South Australian law as at November 2026. It is not legal advice about your situation.