Superannuation death benefit disputes
Superannuation is often a person's largest asset after their home, but it usually does not pass under their will. The fund's trustee decides who receives it, under the fund's rules and superannuation law, unless a valid binding nomination says otherwise. The time limits for challenging the trustee's decision are very short.
Who can receive a super death benefit?
The trustee can pay it to the deceased's dependants or to their estate. Dependants include:
-
a spouse, including a de facto partner
-
children of any age
-
anyone who was financially dependent on the deceased
-
anyone in an interdependency relationship with the deceased, such as a close companion who shared a home and support
Does a binding nomination settle it?
If it is valid, yes: the trustee must follow it. But nominations often fail because they were not in the fund's required form, were not properly witnessed, named someone who is not a dependant, or lapsed. Many funds' binding nominations lapse after three years unless they are non-lapsing. A self-managed super fund's deed sets its own rules.
What can I do if I disagree with the trustee's proposed payment?
Act quickly. Where the trustee notifies potential beneficiaries of how it proposes to pay the benefit, you usually have 28 days to object. If the trustee does not change its decision, you usually have 28 days from its final decision to complain to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA). Miss these deadlines and you may lose the right to challenge the payment.
What does AFCA look at?
Whether the trustee's decision was fair and reasonable in its operation, given the fund's rules, the law and the evidence of each claimant's relationship with, and dependency on, the deceased.
What about self-managed super funds?
AFCA cannot hear disputes about self-managed super funds; they go to court. Who controls the fund after a member dies often decides who receives the benefit, so these disputes can be urgent.
Can super be included in a family provision claim?
Only if it is paid to the estate. A family provision order can be made only "out of the estate of the deceased person" (section 116(1) of the Succession Act 2023 (SA)): property the deceased beneficially owned at death that passes to their executor or administrator (Barns v Barns [2003] HCA 9 at [7]). South Australia has no "notional estate" rules that pull other assets back in (at [38]).
A super death benefit is not property that passes under the will. It is held by the fund trustee and paid under the trust deed and the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth), and a valid binding nomination binds the trustee to pay the nominee: Cantor Management Services Pty Ltd v Booth [2017] SASCFC 122 at [20], [29]. Super the trustee pays directly to a dependant does not become part of the estate: In the Estate of Peter Charles Cornford (Deceased) [2015] SASC 15 at [5]. So a claim cannot reach it.
New South Wales is different. In Kemlo v Kemlo [2010] NSWSC 1331 at [63], a nomination made within a year before death was a "prescribed transaction" under New South Wales law, and the fund was available to be designated as notional estate. South Australia has no equivalent. If the trustee pays the benefit to the estate instead, it is administered like any other estate asset and is available for a claim (Cornford at [4]). A large benefit someone received directly may still be relevant to whether the provision made for a claimant was adequate, because the court can consider any other relevant matter (s 116(2)(c)), although no reported South Australian decision has addressed the point. That is why the trustee's decision matters so much. Read about family provision claims
How we help
-
objections to trustees' proposed payments
-
complaints to AFCA, and responses to complaints by other claimants
-
disputes about self-managed super funds
-
advice to executors on whether to claim super for the estate
-
reviewing binding nominations as part of estate planning
To talk to us about a super death benefit, call 08 8393 1234 or use our contact form.
General information as at November 2026. It is not legal advice about your situation.