top of page

Trusts, companies and businesses in a property settlement

When a couple’s wealth sits in a family trust, a company, a business, a farm or a self-managed super fund, a property settlement is more complex and the stakes are higher. We work with accountants, valuers and forensic accountants to identify what is really in the property pool and to divide it in a way that works, including for tax.

 

Are the assets of a family trust part of the property pool?

They can be, but it depends on the trust deed and the facts. In Kennon v Spry [2008] HCA 56 at [57], French CJ approved the principle that whether trust property “is, in reality, the property of the parties or one of them” depends on “the facts and circumstances of each particular case including the terms of the relevant trust deed”. Dr Spry was sole trustee and could appoint the whole fund to his wife. French CJ held that the trust assets, coupled with that power and her right to due consideration, were “property of the parties to the marriage” (at [62], [66]). Gummow and Hayne JJ reached the same result by a different route. Their Honours held that the property of the parties included the husband’s power to appoint the whole fund to the wife and her right to due administration of the trust (at [126]).

 

There is no automatic rule. The result turns on the deed and on the control the party actually has. Where a party lacks control, the interest may be no more than a financial resource. A beneficiary with a reasonable expectation that the trustee’s discretion will be exercised in their favour has a financial resource to that extent: Hall v Hall [2016] HCA 23 at [54].

 

How is a business valued?

Usually by an independent expert valuer. The value depends on the business’s profits, assets and goodwill, and on how far its income depends on the owner personally. Private expenses run through the business, and income not shown in the accounts, can change the picture considerably. A business can be worth a lot on paper but hard to turn into cash, which affects how a settlement is structured.

 

Can the orders bind a lender, creditor or the tax office?

Yes, within limits. Section 90AE, in Pt VIIIAA, allows the court in s 79 proceedings to make orders directed to a creditor. These include orders substituting one party for the other as debtor and orders changing the parties’ proportions of a debt (s 90AE(1)(a)–(c)). The court may also make other orders that direct a third party or alter a third party’s rights (s 90AE(2)). The power reaches the Commissioner of Taxation as a creditor: Commissioner of Taxation v Tomaras [2018] HCA 62 at [17] per Gageler J.

 

The power is confined by the conditions in s 90AE(3) (Tomaras at [68]–[69] per Gordon J). The order must be reasonably necessary, or reasonably appropriate and adapted, to divide the property. It must not be foreseeable that the debt will go unpaid. The third party must be accorded procedural fairness. The order must be just and equitable. The de facto equivalent is s 90TA.

 

Can parents or other people be joined to the case?

Yes. Section 79AA(10) entitles to be joined a creditor who “may not be able to recover his or her debt if the order were made” (s 79AA(10)(a)), and “any other person whose interests would be affected by the making of the order” (s 79AA(10)(b)). Parents who say that money they gave for a house deposit was a loan may therefore be joined. Whether the advance was a loan or a gift is decided on the evidence. In Masoud & Masoud [2016] FamCAFC 24 at [57], [62], the Full Court upheld a finding, made on the evidence of the wife and her father, that an advance from her parents was a loan governed by a written agreement. Trustees and companies can also be joined where a trust’s or a company’s assets are in issue.

 

Is capital gains tax payable on transfers between us?

Often not, because of the marriage breakdown rollover. Section 126-5 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) provides a rollover for a CGT event between an individual and their spouse or former spouse “because of” a court order under the Act, a binding financial agreement (ss 90G, 90UJ) or a registered arbitral award (s 126-5(1)(a), (d), (da), (e)). Section 126-15 extends the rollover to transfers from a company or trustee to “a spouse or former spouse … of another individual”. “Spouse” includes a de facto partner (s 995-1), so former de facto partners are covered.

 

The relief is conditional. Trading stock is excluded (s 126-5(3)(a)). Only specified CGT events qualify. Rollovers based on a financial agreement also require the parties to be separated with no reasonable likelihood of resuming cohabitation, and the event to be directly connected with the breakdown (ss 126-5(3A), 126-25(1)). The spouse must take as transferee. In Ellison v Sandini Pty Ltd [2018] FCAFC 44 at [176]–[177], Jagot J held that under s 126-15 the spouse is involved “in one capacity only, as transferee”. A transfer by a trustee to a company controlled by the former spouse did not qualify, and was not made “because of” the orders (at [36]).

 

Can a payment from a private company be taxed as a dividend?

Probably, under Division 7A. Section 109C(1) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) deems a private company to pay a dividend where it pays an amount to a shareholder’s associate (s 109C(1)(a)). It also does so where a reasonable person would conclude that the payment was made because the recipient “has been” such an associate (s 109C(1)(b)). A former spouse falls within para (b). The Commissioner’s ruling TR 2014/5 at [6] states that s 109J does not prevent a payment made under a s 79 order from being a deemed dividend. At [79], it states that whether the recipient is still an associate when paid does not matter. The Full Court accepted in Lacey & Lacey [2020] FamCAFC 73 at [47]–[48] that cash paid by the husband’s company to his former wife “would probably be deemed as a dividend in her hands”. That probable liability was relevant to whether the orders were just and equitable.

 

Two cautions apply. The ruling binds the Commissioner, not the courts, and the ruling itself records that it is under review following Ellison. No court has decided that Div 7A applies to a payment made under family law orders. Where the company transfers property rather than cash, the ruling treats the s 126-15 rollover consequences as also applying (TR 2014/5 at [10]). Money taken out of a private company by a shareholder and recorded as a loan also affects the property pool, and an undocumented loan can have its own Division 7A consequences. We work with your accountant to structure a settlement that does not create an unexpected tax bill.

 

Is stamp duty payable?

The exemption rests on State law alone. Section 90 of the Act purports to exempt instruments executed under its orders from State duty, but the High Court held that provision invalid in its application to duty imposed by State law: Gazzo v Comptroller of Stamps (Vic) [1981] HCA 73; (1981) 149 CLR 227. The relief available in South Australia is therefore whatever the Stamp Duties Act 1923 (SA) grants. Section 71CA(2)(b) exempts an instrument “to give effect to, or consequential on” a family law order. Family law agreements are exempt under s 71CA(2)(a), and instruments executed by a superannuation trustee to give effect to an order or agreement are exempt under s 71CA(2)(c).

 

The s 71CA(2)(b) exemption has three conditions. The order must relate to a marriage that has been dissolved or annulled, or to a marriage or de facto relationship the Commissioner is satisfied has broken down irretrievably. The instrument must dispose of property between the parties, with no other person, apart from a superannuation trustee, taking an interest. The parties must be, or have been, married or in a de facto relationship with each other. A transfer under orders to a child, a company, a family trust or a purchaser therefore falls outside s 71CA, which shapes how settlements involving trusts and companies are structured. Duty paid only because irretrievable breakdown was not yet established is refundable once it is (s 71CA(3)).

 

Separately, s 71CB exempts an instrument whose sole effect is to transfer an interest in the shared residence, or a motor vehicle, between spouses or domestic partners, whether or not a court has made orders. Between former partners, it applies only if the Commissioner is satisfied that the instrument was executed as a result of the irretrievable breakdown (s 71CB(3)), and it does not extend to industrial or commercial premises.

 

What about farms and rural properties?

Farms are often held across trusts, companies and partnerships with other family members, and may have been built up over generations. Contributions from parents, the farm’s viability and the family’s wish to keep it together all matter. Settlements may involve staged payments, partial transfers or restructuring rather than a sale.

 

What happens to a self-managed super fund?

A member’s interest in a self-managed fund can be split like any other super. That may mean rolling one member’s balance out to another fund, transferring assets in specie, or changing the trustees. The fund must stay compliant with superannuation law throughout.

 

How we help

  • mapping the structures and identifying what is in the property pool

  • briefing business valuers and forensic accountants

  • settlement structures that work for tax, duty and the business

  • dealing with trustees, companies, lenders and other third parties

  • court proceedings where agreement is not possible

To talk to us about a separation involving trusts, companies or a business, call 08 8393 1234 or use our contact form.

General information about Australian family law as at November 2026. It is not legal or tax advice about your situation.

von Doussas · est. 1872

Old Post Office House, 33 Hutchinson Street, Mount Barker SA 5251 · 08 8393 1234 · info@vondoussas.com.au

von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd · ABN 45 096 967 163 · An incorporated legal practice

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

© 2026 von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd · Privacy policy

Sandstone office building with blue von Doussas sign
bottom of page