top of page

Disputes with executors and administrators

An executor holds the estate for the beneficiaries and must act honestly, promptly and even-handedly. When they do not, beneficiaries have real rights. We also act for executors facing unreasonable demands or unfounded allegations.

 

What can I do if the executor is delaying?

Start by asking, in writing, what has been done and what remains. Many delays have a reason, such as a property sale, a tax issue or a pending claim. If there is no good reason, a lawyer's letter often gets things moving. If it does not, the Supreme Court can order the executor to take steps, or replace them.

 

Am I entitled to see the will and the estate accounts?

You are entitled to see the will if you are named in it or are one of the other people the Succession Act 2023 (SA) lists. Read about deceased estates A beneficiary is also entitled to information about the estate. If an executor or administrator will not account, the Supreme Court can order them to provide a statement and account of the estate.

 

Can an executor be removed?

Yes. The Supreme Court has jurisdiction "to make and revoke a grant of probate ... or letters of administration" (Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 18(1)(a)), now read with the Succession Act 2023 (SA): Polites v Salkanovic [2026] SASCA 2 at [108] per Bleby JA.

 

Before a grant, the court can pass over the executor named in the will and appoint an administrator instead, on grounds including neglect of duties, unsound mind, ill health and disappearance (Polites at [139]). It can also grant probate or administration to someone other than the person entitled where that is appropriate for the proper administration of the estate and in the interests of those interested in it (Succession Act s 67(1)).

 

After a grant, the court can remove an executor or administrator, or revoke the grant. The test is the due and proper administration of the estate in the interests of those beneficially entitled: Mullins-Trnovsky v Adams [2014] SASC 116 at [14], [18]. Grounds include neglect of duties, misconduct, serious conflicts of interest and incapacity. The court can remove one of several executors without revoking the grant, and should revoke a grant only where no other appropriate remedy exists (at [30]). It "will not readily revoke a grant of probate when its grant was valid", but did so where hostility between executors made proper administration a "near impossibility": In the Estate of Raymond Francis Stuart [2009] SASC 399 at [26]. Where an executor fails in their duties, s 98 of the Succession Act also allows the court to make "any order it considers appropriate".

 

What if the executor has a conflict of interest?

An executor who is also a beneficiary, lives in an estate property, owes the estate money or is in business with the estate must not put their own interests ahead of the estate's. Conflicts are common in family estates; they do not automatically disqualify an executor, but they must be managed openly.

 

Can an executor be made to pay for losses?

Yes. An executor who breaches their duties, for example by selling property at an undervalue, paying the wrong people or delaying unreasonably, can be personally liable for the loss. The Succession Act 2023 (SA) now gives beneficiaries a clear statutory path to bring proceedings against an executor who breaches their duties. The court can order the executor to repay any benefit they gained or compensate those who suffered loss. The application must be made within 3 years of the beneficiary becoming aware of the failure.

 

I am an executor. How do I protect myself?

  • Keep a separate estate account and full records.

  • Keep beneficiaries informed, in writing.

  • Do not distribute until the time for family provision claims has passed, and any claim is resolved.

  • When a decision is difficult or disputed, ask the Supreme Court for advice or directions; acting on that advice protects you.

  • Get legal advice early; reasonable legal costs are paid from the estate.

 

Can an executor charge for their work?

An executor's reasonable expenses are repaid from the estate. Payment for their time and trouble, called commission, is allowed only if the will contains a charging clause or the Supreme Court allows it. Section 96(1) of the Succession Act 2023 (SA) provides that the court "may allow an executor, administrator or trustee ... such commission or other remuneration out of the estate or trust property ... as the Court considers just and reasonable". It replaced s 70 of the Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA) on 1 January 2025. Without a charging clause, an executor "is only able to be remunerated by way of an application for the payment of commission from the estate": In the Estate of Peter McBride (Deceased) [2019] SASC 204 at [22]. The application is made by originating application, supported by an affidavit and verified accounts, and the beneficiary out of whose share the commission would be paid must be joined (r 357.9 of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA)).

 

An executor must not pay themselves first. Of executors who had done so, Griffith CJ said they "had, of course, no right to take it until it had been allowed by the Court": Nissen v Grunden [1912] HCA 35. The test is whether an allowance is just and reasonable, and no special circumstances need be shown: Zwart v Westley [2025] SASC 132 at [97], [102]. Commission compensates "pains" and "trouble". The court weighs the time taken, the size and complexity of the estate, the work done, the executor's diligence and how much was paid to professionals from the estate (at [100]–[101], [103]).

 

A right to apply is not a right to be paid. The executor must satisfy the court that they have been "faithful, honest and diligent" in performing the trust: Chiro v Linton (No 2) [2009] SASC 197 at [13]. There, the executor's inordinate delay in distributing the estate disentitled him to commission, although he had committed no fraud or breach of trust (at [21]); more often, delay leads to a reduction rather than a refusal (at [22]). An administrator who fails to provide the statement and account required by s 92, or fails to dispose of the estate in the due course of administration, is not entitled to commission (s 96(2)). Professional executors, such as trustee companies, usually charge under the will.

 

How we help

  • demanding information and accounts from executors

  • negotiating with executors and their lawyers

  • applications to compel accounts, remove an executor or recover losses

  • advising executors on their duties and protecting them from unfair claims

  • applications for the court's advice or directions

To talk to us about a problem with an executor, call 08 8393 1234 or use our contact form.

General information about South Australian law as at November 2026. It is not legal advice about your situation.

von Doussas · est. 1872

Old Post Office House, 33 Hutchinson Street, Mount Barker SA 5251 · 08 8393 1234 · info@vondoussas.com.au

von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd · ABN 45 096 967 163 · An incorporated legal practice

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

© 2026 von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd · Privacy policy

Sandstone office building with blue von Doussas sign
bottom of page