top of page

Commercial and retail leases

A lease often outlasts the business plan it was signed for. We draft and advise on commercial and retail leases for landlords and tenants, and act when lease disputes arise.

 

Is my lease a retail shop lease?

Many leases of shops and premises used for retail trade or services to the public are covered by the Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA). Despite its name, the Act applies only to retail shop leases. It does not apply, for example, while the rent exceeds a prescribed threshold, to leases of one month or less, or where the tenant is a public company or (for leases entered into from the prescribed day) a company incorporated overseas (s 4(2)). Other commercial leases are governed by the lease itself and the general law. Whether the Act applies changes the parties' rights significantly, so it is the first thing to check.

 

What does the Act do?

For a retail shop lease, among other things, it requires the landlord to give the tenant a signed disclosure statement before the lease is entered into (section 12(1)), although not on a renewal (s 12(1a)), controls how outgoings and certain costs can be passed on, regulates rent reviews and assignments, and provides a process for resolving disputes. If the disclosure statement is not given, or is materially false or misleading, the Magistrates Court can vary or avoid the lease or order repayment or compensation (s 12(5)), unless the landlord acted honestly and reasonably and the tenant was not substantially prejudiced (s 12(6)): De Bourbel Pty Ltd (in liq) v Distilleria Pty Ltd [2023] SASC 88 at [240]. Many of the Act's protections apply whatever the lease says.

 

What should I check before signing a lease?

  • the term, any options to renew, and how and when an option must be exercised

  • the rent, and how and when it is reviewed

  • outgoings: which costs the tenant pays

  • the permitted use of the premises

  • fit-out, and the make-good obligations at the end of the lease

  • repairs and maintenance

  • assignment and subletting

  • guarantees, bank guarantees and security deposits

  • relocation and demolition clauses

 

How do I exercise an option to renew?

Exactly as the lease requires, and within the time it allows. Missing the window or using the wrong method can lose the right to renew. Put the date in your diary when you sign.

 

Can I assign my lease when I sell my business?

Usually, with the landlord's consent. For a retail shop lease, the Act does not ask whether consent is unreasonably withheld. Section 43(1) allows the landlord to withhold consent only if the proposed new tenant intends to change the use of the premises, is unlikely to meet the tenant's financial obligations under the lease, or has retailing skills inferior to yours, or if you have not followed the procedure for asking for consent. The landlord "is not entitled to withhold that consent in any other circumstances", so even a reasonable objection outside that list is not enough. The landlord must give written reasons for refusing (s 43(2)), and is taken to have consented if it does not respond within 42 days of a proper request (s 45(d)). No reported decision has construed s 43, but its text is clear. For other leases, the lease decides, and many say that consent cannot be unreasonably withheld. Read about buying or selling a business

 

What happens in a lease dispute?

Common disputes involve rent arrears, outgoings, repairs, breaches, termination notices and make-good. For a retail shop lease, the Small Business Commission, constituted by the Small Business Commissioner, is responsible for arranging the resolution of disputes (section 63(1)). Either party can apply (s 63(2)), and the Commission chooses the form of dispute resolution, so mediation is one option rather than the only one (s 63(3)). The Commission can also take up a dispute on its own initiative (s 66(1)); a party can object within 10 business days, and the Commission then decides whether to proceed (s 66(3)–(4)). It can require attendance and the production of documents (s 66A), and can decline disputes that are trivial or vexatious, unlikely to be resolved that way, or better handled by another agency (s 63(4)). An agreement recorded in writing and signed by the Commission and the parties can be enforced in the Magistrates Court (s 68A).

 

Mediation is not a precondition in South Australia. Either party can start proceedings in the Magistrates Court (s 68(1)), which can refer the dispute to the Commission and stay the case while it does (s 65). Victoria is different: there, absent a claim for an injunction, parties to a retail tenancy dispute "must first participate in a mediation conducted under the auspices of the Small Business Commissioner": Ajaimi v Giswick Pty Ltd [2022] VSC 131 at [169].

 

How we help

  • drafting leases for landlords

  • reviewing and negotiating leases for tenants

  • options, renewals, assignments and subleases

  • lease disputes, including mediation and court proceedings

To talk to us about a lease, call 08 8393 1234 or use our contact form.

General information about South Australian law as at November 2026. It is not legal advice about your situation.

von Doussas · est. 1872

Old Post Office House, 33 Hutchinson Street, Mount Barker SA 5251 · 08 8393 1234 · info@vondoussas.com.au

von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd · ABN 45 096 967 163 · An incorporated legal practice

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

© 2026 von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd · Privacy policy

Sandstone office building with blue von Doussas sign
bottom of page