Funeral and burial disputes
Disagreements about a funeral, burial, cremation or ashes are among the most painful family disputes, and they cannot wait. Call us as soon as a dispute arises; we can act at short notice.
Who decides about the funeral and burial?
The executor named in a valid will. Where a person dies with sufficient property, the duty of burial falls on the personal representative, which is the executor named in the will: Marschall v Elson [2023] SASCA 1 at [59]. Applying that statement, the Supreme Court held in Maros v Luca [2024] SASC 98 at [96] that "the executor named in a valid will has the right to possession of the deceased's body for the purpose of its disposal". The executor has the duty, as well as the right, to arrange the funeral and the burial or cremation.
If there is no will, or the will or the executor's appointment is disputed, there is no automatic answer. The person entitled to administer the estate, often the spouse or domestic partner and then the adult children, is the usual starting point, but the court applies a flexible balancing of legal principle, practical considerations, cultural and religious matters, and the wishes of the deceased and the family: Marschall at [59]; Maros at [103].
Can someone stop a cremation?
Yes, in some cases. Under section 9(3) of the Burial and Cremation Act 2013 (SA), it is an offence to cremate a body knowing that the deceased's personal representative, parent or child objects, unless the deceased directed cremation in their will or another signed and witnessed document. A cremation permit cannot be issued in those circumstances either (s 10(7)). So even an executor cannot go ahead with a cremation over such an objection unless the deceased directed it.
Are the deceased's wishes binding?
Not strictly. Wishes in a will or elsewhere are not legally binding, but executors usually follow them, and a court will give them real weight, along with cultural and religious beliefs.
What happens if the family cannot agree?
An urgent discussion or mediation often resolves it. If not, a family member can apply to the Supreme Court, which has inherent jurisdiction to grant an injunction to stop a burial or cremation and to declare who is entitled to carry it out: Maros at [28]. It decides these disputes promptly, often within days, because the dignity of the deceased requires a quick decision on the mode and place of burial: Marschall at [59], [64]. The court takes a practical approach, weighing the deceased's wishes, the views of those closest to them, cultural and religious practices, and the need for the funeral to happen without delay.
Who decides what happens to the ashes?
Usually the person entitled to arrange the funeral, typically the executor. Disputes about keeping, dividing or scattering ashes can also go to court, although they are best resolved by agreement.
Who pays for the funeral?
Reasonable funeral costs are paid from the estate before other debts. Whoever paid them is usually reimbursed from the estate.
How we help
-
urgent advice on who has the right to decide
-
negotiating with family members at short notice
-
urgent applications to the Supreme Court
-
disputes about ashes and memorials
To talk to us about a funeral or burial dispute, call 08 8393 1234 straight away.
General information about South Australian law as at November 2026. It is not legal advice about your situation.