Challenging a will for lack of capacity
A will is valid only if the person making it had testamentary capacity when they signed it. As more people live longer with dementia and other conditions that affect the mind, capacity disputes have become one of the fastest-growing areas of estate litigation. We act for people challenging a will, and for executors and beneficiaries upholding one.
What is testamentary capacity?
It is the mental ability to make a will. The test comes from the 1870 English case Banks v Goodfellow, which Australian courts still apply. When signing, the will-maker must:
-
understand that they are making a will and what it does
-
know, in general terms, what they own
-
be aware of the people who might expect to benefit, and be able to weigh their claims
-
not be affected by a mental illness or delusion that distorts those choices
Capacity can change from day to day. A person with dementia may still have capacity at a particular moment, and a person without a diagnosis may lack it.
Who has to prove capacity?
If a will looks rational and was properly signed, the court presumes the will-maker had capacity. Once evidence raises a real doubt, the people relying on the will must prove that the will-maker had capacity when they signed it.
What evidence matters?
-
medical records from the GP, specialists, hospitals and aged-care homes, including cognitive test results
-
the will file of the lawyer who prepared the will: their notes, and any medical assessment they obtained
-
evidence from the witnesses and others who saw the will-maker around that time
-
earlier wills, and whether the new will departs from them without a clear reason
-
opinions from geriatricians or psychiatrists who review the records after death
How can I stop probate being granted while I investigate?
By lodging a caveat with the Probate Registry of the Supreme Court (section 62(1) of the Succession Act 2023 (SA)). Under r 354.1(1) of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA), a person who "wishes to ensure that no grant is issued without notice to them" may enter a caveat. While it is in force, the Registry tells anyone who applies for a grant about the caveat, and tells you about their application (r 354.2), so no grant is made without notice to you. That gives time to obtain the records and advice needed to decide whether to challenge the will.
A caveat "remains in force for six months only" from the date it is sealed (r 354.1(5)), and can be renewed for further six-month periods (r 354.1(6)). Renew it before the six months expire: unless the court otherwise orders, a caveator may not enter a further caveat while one is in force or after it has ceased to have effect (r 354.7), and that may catch a caveat that has simply lapsed. A caveat does not affect a grant made on the day it is sealed (r 354.1(7)). A person claiming an interest in the estate can "warn" the caveat, and if you do not enter an appearance, the court can order that it cease to have effect (r 354.4(5)–(6)). A challenge is much harder once probate has been granted and the estate distributed.
What happens if the will is found invalid?
The court will admit the most recent earlier valid will to probate instead. If there is none, the estate passes under the intestacy rules. Family members may still be able to make a family provision claim. Read about family provision claims.
Can the court make a will for someone who has lost capacity?
Yes. The Supreme Court can authorise a will, or a change to an existing will, for a person who lacks capacity. These applications are increasingly common where a person's circumstances change after they have lost capacity, for example when their home is sold or a beneficiary dies.
How can a will-maker reduce the risk of a dispute?
When we prepare a will for someone whose capacity might later be questioned, we can arrange a medical assessment at the time, keep detailed notes of the instructions, and record the reasons for their choices. Evidence made at the time is far stronger than recollections years later.
Does capacity matter for other documents?
Yes. Similar questions arise for enduring powers of attorney, lifetime gifts and changes to bank accounts or property ownership. Read about gifts, joint accounts and attorneys
How we help
-
an early assessment of whether a capacity challenge is worth pursuing
-
obtaining medical records and the lawyer's will file
-
briefing medical experts to review the evidence
-
lodging and defending caveats
-
negotiating, mediating and running proceedings in the Supreme Court
-
applications for court-authorised wills
To talk to us about a will you think is invalid, call 08 8393 1234 or use our contact form.
General information about South Australian law as at November 2026. It is not legal advice about your situation.