Undue influence, fraud and suspicious circumstances
A will must reflect the will-maker's own free choices. If it was the product of pressure, deception or forgery, or was made in circumstances that cast doubt on whether the will-maker knew and approved of what it said, it can be challenged.
What is undue influence in a will?
It is pressure that overpowers the will-maker's own wishes, so that the will reflects someone else's choices. Persuasion, appeals to affection or gratitude, and even nagging are allowed; coercion is not. Undue influence is hard to prove, because it usually happens in private and the person alleging it must prove it. It is most often raised where the will-maker was old, unwell, isolated or dependent on the person who benefited.
What are suspicious circumstances?
Circumstances that raise a real doubt about whether the will-maker knew and approved of the will's contents, for example where:
-
a person who benefits arranged the lawyer, gave the instructions or was present when the will was signed
-
a beneficiary wrote or typed the will
-
the will suddenly favours a new carer, friend or adviser
-
the will-maker could not read the will because of poor eyesight, illness or limited English
Once suspicion is raised, the people relying on the will must prove that the will-maker knew and approved of what it said. That burden is often easier to put on them than proving undue influence directly.
What about forgery and fraud?
A forged signature or a fabricated will is invalid. A will can also be set aside for fraud, for example where someone lied to the will-maker about a family member so that they would be cut out. Handwriting experts and the circumstances in which the will appeared are often key evidence.
How are lifetime gifts different?
The rules for gifts made during the giver's life are more favourable to people challenging them. In some relationships the law presumes influence, and a gift obtained by taking advantage of someone's special disadvantage can be set aside as unconscionable. Read about gifts, joint accounts and attorneys
What evidence helps?
-
the lawyer's will file and notes of who gave the instructions
-
medical and aged-care records
-
evidence from the witnesses, carers and neighbours
-
earlier wills, and any explanation for the change
-
emails, texts and bank records showing the relationship with the beneficiary
When do I need to act?
Before probate is granted, if possible. Lodging a caveat with the Probate Registry stops a grant being made without notice to you; it lasts six months and can be renewed. A grant can be revoked later, but by then assets may have been distributed.
How we help
-
assessing the evidence of pressure, fraud or suspicious circumstances
-
obtaining the will file, medical records and handwriting evidence
-
lodging and defending caveats
-
negotiating, mediating and running proceedings in the Supreme Court
-
acting for executors and beneficiaries who need to uphold a will
To talk to us about a will you think was not freely made, call 08 8393 1234 or use our contact form.
General information about South Australian law as at November 2026. It is not legal advice about your situation.