Lifetime gifts, joint accounts and attorneys
Many inheritance disputes are really about what happened before death: money transferred, property signed over, bank accounts made joint, or an attorney using the person's funds as their own. Those assets may never reach the estate unless someone acts. This is a growing area as more people manage an older parent's finances.
Can a gift made before death be challenged?
Yes, if the gift was made when the giver:
-
lacked the mental capacity to understand what they were doing
-
was under undue influence, which the law presumes in some relationships of trust and dependence
-
was at a special disadvantage that the person receiving the gift took advantage of (unconscionable conduct)
After death, the executor or administrator usually brings the claim for the estate. While the giver is alive, their attorney or a guardian may be able to.
Who owns the money in a joint bank account after death?
Usually the surviving account holder, automatically. But if the evidence shows the deceased added the other person only for convenience, for example so they could pay bills, the survivor may hold the money on trust for the estate. Bank records, who paid money in and what the deceased said about the account all matter.
What must an attorney under an enduring power of attorney do?
An attorney must act honestly and in the interests of the person who appointed them. In particular, they must:
-
keep that person's money and property separate from their own
-
keep accurate records of everything they do
-
avoid conflicts between their own interests and that person's
-
not make gifts or pay themselves unless the power of attorney allows it
What can be done if an attorney has misused their power?
Anyone with a proper interest can apply to the Supreme Court under section 11 of the Powers of Attorney and Agency Act 1984 (SA). The court can order the attorney to file and serve all records and accounts (s 11(1)(a)), have them audited (s 11(1)(b)), and revoke or vary the power or appoint a substitute attorney (s 11(1)(c)). Section 11 is "the vehicle by which a person with a proper interest in the matter may make a subsequent claim against the donee of a power of attorney": Furina v Cooke [2017] SASC 45 at [14]. The Supreme Court's jurisdiction is not exclusive (at [7]), so ordinary civil claims against an attorney can be brought in other courts, but the s 11 powers belong to the Supreme Court.
The South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT) does not have those powers, and can affect an attorney only indirectly. If the person has lost capacity, SACAT can appoint an administrator of their estate (Guardianship and Administration Act 1993 (SA) s 35). The attorney is then accountable to the administrator, who has the same power to revoke the power as the person would have had (s 10 of the Powers of Attorney Act). In AMT v COT & GSZ [2017] SACAT 2 at [59], SACAT upheld the Public Trustee's revocation of an attorney's appointment; the revocation was the administrator's act, not the Tribunal's.
After death, the executor can require the attorney to account for what they did and can sue to recover money that was misused. The Adult Safeguarding Unit can also help where an older person is at risk of financial abuse.
What evidence matters?
-
bank statements and records of transfers
-
the attorney's records, or the lack of them
-
medical evidence of the person's capacity at the time
-
the documents signed, and who arranged them
-
evidence from family, carers and the person's advisers
How we help
-
investigating transactions before death
-
demanding accounts from attorneys
-
recovering money and property for estates
-
defending attorneys and recipients of genuine gifts
-
advising on what an attorney may and may not do
To talk to us about money or property moved before death, call 08 8393 1234 or use our contact form.
General information about South Australian law as at November 2026. It is not legal advice about your situation.